creativity

Off Target: The Difference between Branding and Retail Sameness at Target

Bill Winchester on August 11, 2011 ·

What’s happened to Target? Well, a lot of their advertising has gone stupid-retail for one. Their broadcast has become a big ho-hum that carries very little branding, almost zero concept and this means the brand linkage to Target is completely dependent on three seconds of logo at the end of the spot. Advertising like this relies on consumers actually paying rapt attention–which they don’t–and is a formula that makes it easy for them to confuse Target with one of their competitors.

 

 

 

For instance, check out this recent Target commercial for Champion sportswear:

 

The problem with this ad is it could be for anybody. Is it a Nike commercial? No, it’s really not that good. Is it a Kohl’s commercial? Maybe. It seems like a throwback to some “Softer Side of Sears” era. Lots of pretty pictures, absolutely no concept and worse yet, no brand linkage. If I don’t get bored and change the channel before the end, I wouldn’t know it was Target. Sure, it has Jude Hollywizzle and I guess if you were into street ball (which, I’m guessing, 90% of the soccer mom/Target shoppers aren’t), you’d pay attention. The goal here is to sell the Champion line of clothing , but what about the Target brand?

Here’s the new look for the brand ads that are doing the work supporting Target:

Compare that to this Target commercial from days gone by:

The use of the logo, the iconic use of the color red and the overall energy and vibe of the commercial. Could this commercial be for anyone else?

It seems especially from the retail ad side of things, Target has decided that rather than trade on its iconic brand it will try to be like every other retail chain. Here’s the formula:

  1. Find a pop song.
  2. Find a designer, movie star or a sports star that’s willing to be in your commercial.
  3. Edit a spot with random shots of that person doing random things.
  4. Put your logo in the last three seconds.

J.C. Penny does it. Kohls does it. And now Target. Not exactly differentiating or for that matter memorable.

I realize that brands need to move forward and the advertising needs to change with the times, but Target had a winning formula that put their identity at center stage. It was a celebration of their retail-ness or retailosity or whatever you want to call it, that carried with it a big, fun, hip personality. Different? Check. Memorable? Check. Certainly there’s a way to create new spots that are entertaining, have brand linkage and are, well, Targety.

The question is, do the new brand ads and retail ads do the trick? Do they carry that fun hip vibe of Target? Love to hear your thoughts in comments section.

(post edited to include brand ad)

2 comments

Now Hiring: Creative Technologist

Bill Winchester on June 2, 2011 ·

Creative_TechnologistIn advertising we’ve often mistaken creative technologist for someone who designs websites and also doesn’t mind doing a little coding. Or a writer who can fix your computer. But the real job description is something that is so much more. The confluence of unfettered creativity and the technology to make it happen is rare. The two things seem to live at odds in most people’s brains and being good at one (like coding) often is at the expense of the other (like kinetic movement). Ask most art directors about algebra and you’ll get the idea.

I was surfing and I ran across this and it totally captured my attention. And while I’m not a big fan of America’s Got Talent this is a good example of why, as a creative person you have to keep your eyes and mind open to everything. You just never know when or where something is going to appear.

The woman who created this was a dancer and also into programming (this is the rarity that I’m talking about) created this and it’s a great example of what is meant by a creative technologist. Truly something different.

The million dollar question is, can an advertising agency hire someone like this and keep them engaged? I’d like to try, so if you’re out there we’re looking send me your stuff.

Be the first to comment

Is Design Thinking Really Dead?

April 19, 2011

Impatient companies trying to incorporate design thinking into their organizations have become frustrated with the whole process and like children who’ve played with a toy so much they’ve worn down the batteries, they’re pouting and saying, “It doesn’t work.” Here’s the issue, people who don’t fully understand design thinking have made it a “codified process,” [...]

Read the full article →

Get Lost in the Creative Forest

July 21, 2009

Why getting lost in the creative forest is a good thing When asked where they got an idea, most creative people will think for a minute and say, “It just came to me.” Which is exactly what happened, right after they’d spent some serious time lost in what I’ll call “The Creative Forest.” Great creative [...]

Read the full article →

Critics and Creators

April 7, 2009

There’s been a lot of hoopla lately around Wisconsin with the introduction of a new tagline for the State. The tagline, Live Like You Mean It, has met with the kind of reception usually reserved for people coming from Illinois in Hummers. In the interest of full disclosure, we didn’t create this tagline. The interesting [...]

Read the full article →